Search Book Reviews:
Author Last Name
Book Title
Browse Book Reviews:
Book Reviews Home
Author
Editor
Reviewer
Genre
Rating
Publication Year
See Them All
 Total Book Reviews 1223
SFReader Extras
Author Interviews
Suspended Animation
Firebrand Fiction
Articles

Genre
Science Fiction
Publisher
Random House
Date Published
1987
Review Posted on
4/3/2005
Reviewer Rating

Reader Rating
7

The Songs of Distant Earth written by Arthur C. Clarke
Reviewed by Jack Mangan

If you've read this book, why not
Arthur C. Clarke's 1987 novel, The Songs of Distant Earth, based upon an idea in his 1956 short story of the same name, was apparently written as a counterpoint to "the recent rash of space operas on TV and movies screen". Mr. Clarke strives for foreseeable, feasible technology levels in favor of the fantastic, sometimes far-fetched, sometimes supernatural kinds of plot devices often utilized in science fiction. The same approach is applied to the characters and their choice, sometimes eschewing the dramatic in favor of believable, realistic, and human reactions.

The book depicts a small civilization of displaced seedship colonists on the tranquil, utopian waterworld of Thalassa, thousands of years after the destruction of Earth and Earth's Sun. But then, after generations of a peaceful, unchallenged existence on Thalassa, Earth's last seedship, the Magellan arrives on Thalassa - and - and - and - well. . . not much happens then either.

There are one millions souls inside of the ship, though only a handful are awakened to go and interact with the inhabitants of this unexpected civilization on the islands of Thalassa. What little story there is revolves around the Thalassan girl, Mirissa, her brother Kumar, her boyfriend Brant from the island, and her semi-romantic relationship with Loren from the ship. There's also a bit about a species of underwater lobster-like creatures, whom the humans observe slowly emerging into an intelligent, self-aware species. The characters mostly wax philosophical and react in believable, less-than-dramatic fashion to conflicts. This is the meat of the book, I think, for better or worse. Arthur C. Clarke has said that this is his favorite of his books. Other readers seem to have hot or cold reactions; mine was lukewarm. It's kind of plotless, but chock full of interesting ideas and discourse. If you need huge explosions, evil aliens, and epic laser battles to enjoy a deep space sci-fi piece, then stay away. Otherwise, the substance is there, for those who are open to it.

I have nothing but admiration for Mr. Clarke's widely-recognized contributions to science fiction film and literature, not to mention his impact on science and technology in the real world. Numerous relevant technological forecasts, scientific concepts, and terms have become real-life, either inspired or accurately predicted by his books. But - I've only seen the 2001 films and only read Rendezvous With Rama (which I highly recommend) of Mr. Clarke's other works, so I can't exactly call myself a die-hard fan, aficionado, or student of his career. While I'm admittedly not qualified to put "The Songs of Distant Earth" into context with the rest of his stuff, I will say that Rendezvous With Rama is a much more interesting, more compelling read.

I was drawn in a roundabout fashion to read this book, having first heard Mike Oldfield's brilliant 1996 album, The Songs of Distant Earth,, which is based on the novel. Arthur C. Clarke's book is pretty good; Mike Oldfield's album is a masterpiece.

Comments on The Songs of Distant Earth written by Arthur C. Clarke Add a Comment
Inappropriate comments will be deleted!!
There are no comments on this book.
Top Reviewer Rated

Play Dead

Now Featuring
Abandoned Towers
home page | books: by author - by editor - by genre - by reviewer - by rating - by year | all books | author pages | discussion forum | story contest | contest winners | author interviews | articles | suspended animation | firebrand fiction | review guidelines | how to get reviewed | submit a review |
Get the SyFy channel and your other favorite science fiction programming with Direct TV. Compare programming on Direct TV to Comcast and Dish Network to see why you should choose DirecTV. All your favorite Directv packages include quality programming, and now you can get NFL Sunday Ticket free with the purchase of select packages. Find out why direct tv is the best in satellite television programming.
  All contents Copyright 2000-2013, SFReader.com