Search Book Reviews:
Author Last Name
Book Title
Browse Book Reviews:
Book Reviews Home
Author : Editor : Reviewer
Genre : Rating
Publication Year
See Them All
 Total Book Reviews 992
Search Movie Reviews:
Movie Title
Movie Star
Browse Movie Reviews:
Movie Review Home
Director : Genre : Studio
Reviewer : Rating
Year of Release
See Them All
 Total Movie Reviews 118
SFReader Extras
Author Pages
Discussion Forum
Story Contest
Contest Winners
Author Interviews
Articles
Partner Sites
Suspended Animation, June 21, 2002

The Witch King #1, Limited Edition Preview
$3.50 & 24 pgs.
Phosphorescent Comics
Words:Christian Read
Art: Paul Abstruse

The Witch King is a tease.

Readers will leave the first issue of this new comic book series with more questions than
answers.

Of course, the secret to a successful storytelling tease is to leave the reader not frustrated and disappointed but wanting the answers.

After defending his castle from siege, Gavriel the Witch King commands his brother be brought from his castle dungeons to face him.

Do you want more?

There is no more plot in this issue. Gavril and most of the characters look like elves or devils or gnomes, and backgrounds and architecture suggest Earth. Some of the characters are good, some evil, and all live in the past, present or future.

Do you want to know more?

There is no more setting or characterization. The art in The Witch King is dramatic, exaggerating everything from facial expressions to chest muscles. It smacks of fantasy. Do you want....

Ah, you get the idea. But do you get enough plot, setting, and characterization to leave one hungry or angry?

Dialog is believable, although sparse, pacing is a bit slow, and almost all characterization is suggested by the look of each character and their actions.

You skirt the question, oh great reviewer.

The art has its own visual personality: big, flamboyant and gaudy. Some panels are so packed with images that it is difficult to tell what is happening. Everyone except the artist reads from left to right, and from up to down, so readers will be forced to work hard to visually follow this story. Forced labor is not good in storytelling.

The verdict, oh reviewer?

Did you notice this review is a tease like The Witch King? It doesn't give a thumbs up or
down for this title.

Ain't that the pits.

MV


Shudder at Vance's Light's End horror short stories narrated by actor William Windom at www.plan9.org.
Questions? Comment? E-Mail Suspended Animation at vance@digitalwebbing.com

Any statements made, expressed or implied are solely those of columnists or persons interviewed and do not represent the editorial position of the administration, who does not accept responsibility of such statements. All characters and artwork shown are trademark and © of their respective owners.

Movies!
Anime DVDs
Horror DVDs
Science Fiction & Fantasy DVDs
Books!
SFreader Book Store
Top Books

Left Hand of Darkness

The SFReader Ring
Previous
Random
:
:
Next
List
Moreauvia magazine
SFReader is an Amazon partner. If you're going to buy something from Amazon, please use one of our links to get there. Your purchase helps support SFReader at no additional cost to yourself!
Or, if you're feeling really generous, why not just

home page | books: by author - by editor - by genre - by reviewer - by rating - by year | all books | author pages | discussion forum | story contest | contest winners | author interviews | articles | suspended animation | firebrand fiction | review guidelines | how to get reviewed | submit a review | book store | DVDs: anime - horror - science fiction & fantasy
  All contents Copyright 2000-2008, SFReader.com